Everyone deserves a special treat

Treat yourself to one of our handcrafted creations!

Custom Cookies

We can turn your vision into a set of unique and delicious cookies! Our cookies are appropriate for any occasion... birthdays, baby and bridal showers, weddings, holidays, sporting events, corporate events... or even when you just feel like a sweet treat! Contact us via the "Request Yours" button below for a quote.

No items found.

Our Store

We know you're busy! We know you want memorable, delicious tasting treats for your wedding, bridal shower, birthday, company picnic, or family celebration!  Let us save you time (and make your party table look great!) Choose from our wide variety of indulgent treats. Feel free to contact us if you have something else in mind- we make custom treats as well.

Hot Cocoa Bombs

Our hot cocoa bombs are decadent, handcrafted spheres filled with quality ingredients including Ghirardelli chocolates, Hoosier Hills heavy cream, pure Madagascar vanilla, gourmet sprinkles, and a little magic… the best hot cocoa that you’ve ever tasted! Click the shop button below for more information.

Merry Swiftmas

Be the best parent / grandparent / aunt / uncle ever this year! Order your swiftie this Taylor Swift curated gift box to count down the *13* days of Christmas. IYKYK. Pickup is 12/12 (cookies are marked for 12/13-12/25) Cause you know, 13... Shipping is offered for an additional fee.

Do it Yourself Cookie Kits

Create some special memories by decorating cookies with family and friends. Choose between our cookie kits in your favorite shapes and flavors or an outlined cookie ready for you to paint. Everything you need is included-baked cookies, colored icing in piping bags, sprinkles, or edible paint palettes. Perfect for corporate events, holiday parties, girls night out, or family gatherings, large and small. Gather around for a memorable night of fun-filled decorating - and tasty snacking! Choose from one of our pre-designed kits or let us design one especially for you. Click the shop button below for more information.

Hot Coffee Bombs

Our hot coffee bombs add a delicious pop of flavor to your coffee! These luscious, handcrafted spheres are filled with quality ingredients including Ghirardelli white, dark, and milk chocolates, buttery Clasen and Peter’s caramels by Stover, Hoosier Hills heavy cream, pure Madagascar vanilla, Big Train caramel latte, mocha and espresso powder. Click the shop button below for more information.

Cookie Decorating Classes

Whether you have never held an icing bag in your life or are an experienced cookie decorator looking to learn new techniques, we have the perfect class for you! Everything you need will be provided- from cookies, to icing, sprinkles, and a box to take your awesome creations home. Click the shop button below to find the class that is right for you.

Kaitlyn Gress

I love Theresa’s Small Town Treats! The hot cocoa bombs have stolen my heart, however I recently had the opportunity to try the coffee bombs and they are just as delicious! I love the experience and the flavors! Theresa is so talented.

Misty Fisher

We love Theresa’s Small Town Treats. Her cookies are almost too pretty eat. Almost. They taste even better then they look. Theresa can create any design. My sister and I have taken her decorating class and we were shocked at how much we learned in one class. I purchased her hot chocolate bombs for my family and friends. They were beautiful. The boxes were perfect to attach gift cards. If I’m honest, I hid in my office with the last bomb. After sharing the others, it was mine.

Michele McAtee Erler

I purchased Valentine cookies from Theresa in the past and they were perfection!  From the taste, art work and display, they are the best!  This year I've ordered the cookies you can paint for my grands, nieces and nephews and a combination of hot cocoa bombs and chocolate covered oreo cookies for my mom I will say they are too pretty to eat but I can tell you they will be heaven ! You can count on Theresa's perfection to provide a gift you are so proud to give.  Check out her gallery of her artistic creations!

Brooke Meenach

Theresa’s Small Town Treats are wonderful! They’re not only delicious, but they’re also beautiful and unique. I absolutely love her cookies, hot cocoa bombs, and coffee bombs! I can’t wait to order more for all of the special occasions in our family!

Follow us on social media!

Facebook link icon for Theresa's Small Town TreatsClick here to see more of Theresa's Sweet Treats like custom cookies catering and hot cocoa bombs on Instagram!